Two reviews uncover shifting shopper habits as consumers prioritize affordability, weigh loyalty in opposition to worth hikes and embrace retro tech amid financial uncertainty
This story is a part of “The Playbook,” a weekly column that takes a deep dive into the way forward for enterprise, administration and expertise, with an eye fixed towards sensible purposes for health and wellness executives
Two current shopper traits reviews reveal a big shift within the mindset of right now’s consumers, who’re changing into more and more price-sensitive. Other than considerations over rising costs, a report from First Perception additionally confirmed the potential impression of tariffs on shopper loyalty to retailers and types.
And analysis from Circana revealed an anticipated pullback in higher-priced expertise merchandise, which features a shift towards extra retro-style merchandise.
Within the First Insight report, titled “Tariffs & Belief: Why Retailers Threat Loyalty with Worth Hikes,” researchers discovered that shopper loyalty comes with a price. The examine additionally confirmed a disconnect between how shoppers really feel about worth will increase and the way retail executives will reply.
The examine was based mostly on a survey of 306 CEOs, CFOs and COOs from main retailers and types together with 3,393 shoppers within the U.S., U.Ok. and EU.
“The examine reveals that, despite the fact that 68 % of name and retail executives count on a unfavourable response from clients — and 73 % of shoppers affirm they’d be pissed off by worth will increase — 83 % of executives plan to lift costs anyway,” the report’s authors mentioned. “Customers say they’ll reply to retailers’ choices with both elevated loyalty or decreased belief: Practically 80 % would really feel extra loyal to manufacturers that take in tariff-related will increase, whereas almost three in 4 would abandon their favourite model for a less expensive generic if retail costs rise.”
In line with First Perception, nevertheless, clients’ belief and loyalty are “not solely a perform of manufacturers’ and retailers’ skill to protect pricing when confronted with market forces past their management.”
The study discovered that to take care of buyer loyalty whereas navigating circumstances that put their margins in danger, “77 % of surveyed executives have preemptively communicated worth will increase immediately with clients.”
And for these retailers and types at the moment planning to challenge blanket worth hikes, The Playbook transfer First Perception recommends is that “they as a substitute interact clients immediately to achieve insights on what they’d be prepared to spend and what pricing could be a dealbreaker on merchandise throughout classes. The ensuing insights can inform extra nuanced pricing methods.”
Listed here are a number of the key findings from the report:
- Client Sensitivity to Worth Will increase: Practically one-third of consumers (30 %) say any worth enhance might immediate modifications of their spending habits. Customers are inclined to even the smallest uptick in prices.
- Skepticism About Worth Justifications: Solely 24 % of shoppers polled totally attribute rising prices to tariffs, with many suspecting retailers and types of utilizing tariffs as an excuse. Nonetheless, 54 % imagine that authorities insurance policies are the basis explanation for worth will increase.
- Client Expectations of Retailers: Retailers that increase costs can keep loyalty by taking two key actions: speaking transparently about why costs are rising, and providing packages to offset prices corresponding to loyalty rewards or reductions.
- Model Loyalty Tied to Absorbing Prices: Manufacturers that take in worth will increase stand to achieve robust shopper loyalty, with 79 % of respondents indicating that they’d stay most loyal to manufacturers that defend them from increased costs.
- Vacation Buying Shifts Anticipated: Retail executives foresee notable modifications this vacation season, with 92 % anticipating challenges corresponding to decreased shopper spending (56 %), transport/logistics issues (53 %) and product shortages (40 %).
- Most Affected Retail Classes: Ought to worth hikes persist, consumers say they’ll first in the reduction of on spending within the following classes: residence items and furnishings (54 %), attire and vogue (53 %) and electronics/tech (50 %).
“We will hear consumers’ voices loud and clear, and now’s the time for retail executives to place what they’re saying to work,” mentioned Greg Petro, CEO of First Perception. “Whereas most retailers received’t have the ability to keep away from elevating costs altogether, unilateral worth will increase are a surefire option to lose buyer confidence and belief.”
“There are extra knowledgeable methods of approaching pricing methods and offsetting the burden on clients,” he added. “Prospects are forthcoming about what they’ll spend, what they’ll purchase, and the place they’ll faucet out — retailers merely want to interact them and talk what they’re as much as each step of the best way.”
Why Customers Are Pulling It Ahead
Even with many years underneath my belt as a journalist, I nonetheless study new issues every day. At the moment, I discovered a brand new shopper habits time period: “Pull-forward” shopper buying. This refers to consumers who purchase merchandise sooner than they usually would. It’s often a response to anticipated worth will increase or for a promotion not anticipated to final.
I discovered the time period within the Circana analysis report, which confirmed that pull-forward shopper buying “that supported income positive aspects within the U.S. shopper expertise market throughout the first half of 2025 has waned, and is predicted to end in softer second-half outcomes.”
Whereas total shopper expertise retail greenback gross sales grew 1.5 % within the six months ended June 2025, Circana mentioned its newest “Way forward for Client Expertise” report forecasts full-year gross sales income for the trade to complete only one % above final yr, because the impression of early pull-forward buying is realized alongside a pull-back on spending by shoppers.
“Expertise got here to the forefront of shopper buy choices early within the yr, with an enormous emphasis on IT merchandise because the PC market is coming into a refresh cycle,” mentioned Paul Gagnon, vp and expertise trade advisor for Circana. “Nonetheless, that early enhance is more likely to weigh negatively on the second half because the trade-down habits seen already from cost-conscious shoppers in some product classes expands its attain.”
The information revealed that there was the next unit demand for tech merchandise corresponding to TVs and expensive electronics, however they had been had at a discount. Customers “opted for lower cost alternate options, leading to a two % enhance in unit demand, however a 3 % decline in gross sales income for the class.”
“Nonetheless, innovation and new type components gaining acceptance supported robust progress in classes like sensible glasses and sensible rings, to the tune of almost triple or quadruple final yr’s gross sales income,” the report’s authors mentioned. “Equally, demand for extra retro merchandise like digital point-and-shoot cameras contributed to greenback positive aspects of greater than 40 % within the first half of 2025.”
Circana mentioned shoppers will prioritize spending if costs rise: “Merchandise like soundbars and smartwatches will probably be decrease on the precedence checklist than others, leading to anticipated spending declines in 2025.”
“Financial uncertainty and chronic inflation will strain shopper spending, however deliberate tech improve cycles are anticipated to underpin demand resiliency for a lot of classes,” added Gagnon. “The patron will probably be extra targeted on affordability, even when it means buying and selling down extra incessantly to offset any particular person product worth will increase.”
For inquiries and ideas associated to “The Playbook,” please attain out to [email protected]
